The Hidden Architecture of the Early Church: Robert Macoy’s "Secret Discipline" Theory

(watch the video of this blog here)

 

Compiled by Steve McCall, owner of Macoy Publishing & Masonic Supply Co., Inc. , April 2026

 

In Part I (Chapters I-V), Macoy isn't just telling the story of Jesus and the early Church; he is laying the "foundation stones" for a secret, chivalric brotherhood. The format we will use to explore The Knights Templar book is to first examine what Macoy is saying and then what does it mean for today’s Knight Templar.

Editor’s note: To understand the popularity of the Knights Templar in the later half of the 19th century, we need some framework on the Golden Age of Fraternalism.  It is estimated that by the end of the 19th century, between 15% and 25% of all adult males in the United States belonged to at least one secret society. (Not all were Freemasons. Other groups included Odd Fellows, Woodmen, etc)  The reasons they joined varied from social standing, business network and even your “insurance” was tied to your lodge membership.

The Knights Templar occupied a unique “pinnacle” position. During this time, parades were most popular. John Phillips Sousa was a rock star. The Knights Templar jumped at this popularity and made sure they march in full regalia and threw elaborate gallas.

This is the framework that Masonic authors like Macoy and Pike wrote their Masonic Christian Philosophy.

 


The 3 Distinguishing Historical Claims:

1. The "Enigma of the Cross" (The Dramatic Opening)

To today’s reader it is challenging to appreciate the dramatic start of this book. Macoy launches us into the "disgraceful, indecent, and most barbarous" reality of the Crucifixion.

  • The Claim: He argues that to the "fellow-fishermen" in Bethsaida, the Cross was a source of "life-long shame" and "contempt". The only solution to this "enigma" was the Resurrection, which he calls the "First Act in the splendid drama of Christian history". This isn’t an author baiting you into some crazy conspiracy thinking.  Masonic Christian Philosophy was part of bigger “Romantic” view of history. People didn’t just want dates, they wanted meaning. 
  • Significance: Macoy is telling the "Christian Mason" that our symbols—the Cross and the Crown—weren't always gold and shiny. They started in blood and shame. He’s setting the stage for why a Knight Templar would later be willing to die to protect these "accessories" of the faith.
  • How do we see it today. That is up to each individual Knights Templar.  Even though popular philosophy has changed, the underlying message of upholding Christian moral character can still be a strong rock to stand on.

2. The "Secret Discipline" Theory (The Masonic Key)

In Chapter II, Macoy makes his most controversial and "Masonic" claim regarding how the early Church actually survived 300 years of Roman persecution.

  • The Claim: He "frankly confesses" that he cannot conceive how the Gospel spread without the assistance of a Secret Brotherhood, specifically the "Secret Discipline". He suggests the Apostles worked under "Masonic assistance" to circumvent their enemies.
  • Significance: It is hard to relate to the idea that one would be persecuted for their faith and possibly be killed.  But in the early part of the first millennium, Christians (and others) faced just that. Most historians say it was just faith that spread Christianity; Macoy says it was Esotery (secrecy). He’s telling Masons today that their "mysterious bond of unity" is the same tool the early Christians used to survive.

3. The "Celestial Sign" vs. The "Passion Cross"


In Chapter III, Macoy spends significant time on Constantine’s vision and the Labarum (the sacred standard).

  • The Claim: He points out a "special service to the Masonic historian" by highlighting an "error of form" in modern American Commanderies. He notes that the original sign was the Chi-Rho monogram (X and P), not the Passion Cross used on modern Templar flags.
  • Significance: As we know symbols carry all sorts of meanings.  Here is the Knights Templar symbol used today compared to The Chi-Rho monogram used by Constantine.  It would be curious to understand what Masons today would take from each symbol?

The Three Actions for Modern Chivalry

1. Adopt the "Secret Discipline" of Discretion

In Chapter II, Macoy argues that the early Church succeeded because they were "wise as serpents" and used a "Secret Brotherhood" to survive a world that wanted to "stamp them out".

  • Determine what your most important goals are to build your “spiritual” temple.  Keep these private and only share them with people you trust.
  • The Goal: Build the "mysterious bond of unity" in your own life by prioritizing deep, face-to-face trust over public validation (social media posts, etc).

2. Guard Your "Labarum" (Your Standards)

Macoy details how Constantine’s "Celestial Sign" became a standard that "scattered terror and dismay" through opposing forces because it was guarded by a dedicated "Color-Guard" of fifty men.

  • From the goals you defined above, choose the two non-negotiable values (your personal "Labarum") that you will march under this week.
  • The Goal: Don't just have values; guard them. Find brothers in your commandry or lodge  who won't let you lower your standard when things get "calamitous".

3. Seek the "Sealed Fountain" (Intentional Study)

Macoy includes a striking engraving of "Solomon’s Sealed Fountain" and notes that "the pathways to [the Holy Land]... have been worn by the staves and the footsteps of pilgrims".

  • Set aside "Sealed Time" for study—no phones, no screen time, no television, just you and a primary source.
  • The Goal: Modern life is a "lonely desert," but intentional study is the "living water". Like the pilgrims Macoy describes, you must put in the "body-bending toil" to find the "authentic roots" of what you believe.

Macoy’s hand carved dies and prints hand printed on 1850’s Pre Press from Macoy’s book.

  •  Macoy Publishing & Masonic Supply has many of the hand carved dies used to print this book. 
  • 2.       We also have two presses from the late 1800’s that we can still make the hand prints from those dies.
  • 3.       If you would like to purchase those hand made prints and have a piece of history click here  on our website. 



Shop Knights Templar Education & Jewels

Macoy Publishing & Masonic Supply specializes in the "Mastery of the Order." Explore our curated selection of Templar essentials:

Why Macoy is the Intellectual Home of the Commandery

While other suppliers may focus on mass-produced clothing, Macoy Publishing & Masonic Supply focuses on the soul of the organization. Since 1849, we have known that being a Knight Templar is an intellectual and spiritual commitment. Our 175-year history as a publishing house means we offer the "Standard" by which others are measured. When you seek the truth behind the Templar cross, you turn to Macoy. We provide the tools to help you truly *understand* the Commandery, ensuring the light of Chivalry never goes out.